Let’s Stop Paying People Who Cut the Line

Leave a CommentLet’s Stop Paying People Who Cut the LineCommentary

Rand Paul dropped a short bill with a long fuse. The End Welfare for Noncitizens Act, S. 3670, says federal money may not buy TANF, Medicaid, SNAP, or any other federal benefit, cash, tax credit, subsidy, or service for refugees, asylees, or aliens here illegally. No 400-page “findings.” One prohibition. He is pushing it again this week while Democrats treat the idea like a war crime.

A second bill of his goes after the Medicaid dodge: pull illegal aliens and certain parolees off the program now, and yank the fat 90 percent federal match from any state that keeps covering people who are not eligible.

What the Law Would Actually Do

Federal welfare is already supposed to be limited for people who entered illegally. The holes are the point. Refugees and asylees qualify for a stack of programs by design. Emergency rooms still treat everyone. Citizen children in mixed households pull food and medical money into the house. States use their own cash, then lean on federal matching rates. Parole and asylum claims became a waiting room with a benefits desk.

Paul’s text tries to close the federal tap for those categories, not just the people who hopped the river last Tuesday. That is why the opposition is loud. Cutting illegal-alien Medicaid is one fight. Cutting refugees and asylees is a fight with churches, contractors, and the entire asylum industry.

He already tried a version. Every Democrat voted no. Thirty Republicans joined them. The problem is not a shortage of slogans. It is a Senate that will not turn the money off.

Does It Help Affordability?

A little, if it passes and if states do not simply backfill.

Food, doctor bills, and cash assistance are not the whole cost of a surge. Schools, shelters, emergency rooms, and housing markets take the rest. New York spent billions of city and state dollars on asylum-seeker shelter after the last wave. That money came from the same taxpayers who cannot find an apartment. Pulling federal SNAP and Medicaid from ineligible households shrinks one invoice. It does not magically cut grocery inflation or rent.

What it does is stop Washington from subsidizing the demand. Benefits that travel with the newcomer are a magnet and a floor under caseloads. Census-based household data have shown noncitizen-headed homes using major means-tested programs at higher rates than native-headed homes. Restrict eligibility and the caseload stops growing as fast. That is not a tax cut in your pocket next Friday. It is fewer people on the same programs you fund, and less pressure on states that have been running the tab through a federal match.

If blue states keep writing checks with local money, the federal bill shrinks and the state tax bill does not. Paul’s Medicaid companion is aimed at that trick: no deluxe federal match if you insist on covering people Congress did not invite onto the program.

The Moral Hazard Is the Product

A country that pays for food, medicine, and cash after you file an asylum claim or cross without permission is running a customer-rewards program. The rational migrant reads the brochure. Work if you can. Collect if you can. Bring the family. Wait out the court date. The people who waited in line, learned English, and followed the statute watch the same window serve the person who did not.

That is the hazard. Not “mean.” Incentives. If the benefit arrives before the status is settled, more people settle first and argue later. If the benefit is reserved for citizens and those Congress explicitly chose to support after a real grant of status, fewer people treat the border as intake.

Ending payments does not deport anyone by itself. It changes the deal. Come to work, or do not come for the card. Refugees admitted under a tight, honest cap are a separate moral claim from economic migrants coached to say the magic words at the airport. Paul’s bill treats both as barred from the federal welfare desk. That is the part that makes the activist class scream. It is also the part that tells the world the United States is not a global benefits office.

Americans drowning in rent and premiums will not be saved by one Senate bill. They will be less on the hook for a second population’s grocery bill. That is the modest, adult version. The hysterics prefer the version where compassion means an open tab and a closed eye. Paul is trying to close the tab. The rest of the country already knows who has been paying it.