Duffy Asks Congress for $50 Billion After Nationwide Ground Stop Strands Travelers

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy is asking Congress for $50 billion to rebuild the country’s air traffic control system after a communications failure grounded every flight in the United States for nearly four hours on Friday.

The Federal Aviation Administration ordered the nationwide ground stop around 4 p.m. Eastern and lifted it at about 8:15 p.m., The Hill and Reuters reported. Reuters called it the longest shutdown of U.S. airspace since the Sept. 11 attacks. By 11:30 p.m., nearly 10,000 flights had been canceled, according to Flightradar24 figures cited by Reuters.

What failed

Duffy said the trouble started with equipment, not an attack. “Our switches, our routers, actually got overloaded with data,” he said at a White House briefing Friday night. “They started to give us inconsistency in the data from those … routers. And because of that, we shut the system down.”

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin stood with him. “We have seen zero evidence that this is a cyberattack,” Mullin said, according to a DHS release. “This is a national security risk because our air traffic control system is outdated and it hasn’t been a priority from Congress. This is what happens when Congress kicks the can down the road.”

On Saturday, Duffy said the outage came while a contractor at one of the FAA’s remote sites was making a routine switch from copper to fiber wiring. “So, what we’re working to determine was whether we had incompetence — meaning was it user error or install error from L3Harris — or did they install a faulty router? We haven’t determined what the fault was,” he said, as reported by the Daily Caller News Foundation.

The price tag

Duffy had asked Congress for about $30 billion in September. On Friday he raised the request. “I want $50 billion,” he said. “Let’s finish this job: new hardware, new software, new telecommunication.” Mullin said, “It has to be a complete overhaul of the system, which we estimate to be about $50 billion.”

Duffy said Congress has so far given the department $12.5 billion, which he called a “partial payment,” because lawmakers were not sure the FAA would spend it well. He said that money has already replaced 69% of copper lines with fiber, modernized 469 radio sites and put electronic flight strips in 25 towers.

“If we don’t start to switch out our systems, how long are we going to wait? I think this [outage] is a sign for [Congress] to lean in. This is bipartisan,” he said Saturday.

Critics on both sides jumped in. New York Gov. Kathy Hochul, a Democrat, called for Duffy to resign. Former Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene called the request a “shakedown” and wrote that Washington has spent “like $15 trillion on foreign wars over the past 25 years.”

The bottom line

I understand the frustration with a $50 billion request. But Friday was the result of an air traffic system that both parties let age for decades on copper lines and paper flight strips. The FAA’s own record of wasting money is the reason Congress has been stingy, and Duffy is right to show what the first $12.5 billion bought before he asks for more.

Congress should fund the overhaul, with a hard schedule and public progress reports. It should also demand a full account of what happened at that remote site and hold the contractor responsible if the fault was theirs.

Thanksgiving is ten days away, and millions of families will be flying. Lawmakers who want to blame Duffy should first vote on the money to fix the system.