A clip of Stephen Miller on CNN started circulating again over the weekend, and I stopped on it for the same reason a lot of you did. He would not let a softer word stand in for the law.
The interview is from May 30, 2025, on CNN’s “The Situation Room.” Pamela Brown was asking Miller, then the White House deputy chief of staff for policy, about a case in which Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem had said an “undocumented migrant” sent a letter threatening to kill President Trump. Brown added that CNN’s reporting showed investigators believed the man had been set up. Before he would go any further, Miller asked a simple question: “Are you saying this immigrant was here illegally?”
Brown said yes. She had already used “undocumented.” When she asked for a “good faith discussion,” Miller answered, “When we use language that’s designed to obscure the truth, that’s not good faith. An illegal alien is an illegal alien. They’re not an undocumented migrant.”
He is right, and the statute is on his side. Federal immigration law still says “alien.” 8 U.S.C. § 1252c is titled, in part, “illegal aliens.” “Undocumented” makes a violation of federal law sound like a paperwork problem. That is not a slip. It is the point.
This is bigger than one word on one cable show. The method is always the same. First you replace the accurate term with a cuddlier one. Then you treat anyone who uses the old, precise word as unkind. Then the public is arguing about manners instead of about the thing itself.
“Pro-choice” is the classic. It has been the preferred label of abortion-rights groups for decades, including NARAL Pro-Choice America, because “choice” is warmer than the procedure it describes. After the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade, the Biden White House went further. On July 8, 2022, two weeks after Dobbs, President Biden signed an executive order titled “Protecting Access to Reproductive Health Care Services.” The White House fact sheet said the Court had “eliminated a woman’s Constitutional right to choose” and that Biden would “protect access to safe and legal abortion.” The order’s title still wrapped that debate in the language of ordinary medicine.
“Gender-affirming care” does the same work. In 2022, the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Population Affairs issued a fact sheet, “Gender-Affirming Care and Young People,” that called early treatment “crucial to overall health and well-being” and described an “array of services that may include medical, surgical, mental health, and non-medical services.” The gentle phrase covers puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries, including in adolescents. A name that sounds like kindness is being used to close the argument before the evidence is even heard.
The same habit showed up in the streets. On Aug. 25, 2020, as CNN correspondent Omar Jimenez stood in Kenosha, Wisconsin, in front of a building on fire, the network’s on-screen caption read, “FIERY BUT MOSTLY PEACEFUL PROTESTS AFTER POLICE SHOOTING.” The Hill and Fox News both recorded the chyron at the time. A city can be burning in the shot, and the language still asks you to look away.
Congress can play the game too. The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, the official short title of Public Law 117-169, was sold as relief from high prices. Bloomberg, the day before it was signed, called it “a climate bill by another name.” The law’s core was hundreds of billions of dollars in climate and energy subsidies, along with tax and health-care provisions. Whatever else one thinks of those policies, “inflation reduction” was a slogan, not a description.
You can find the same softening in criminal law and at the end of life. A Biden White House fact sheet from April 25, 2024, on Second Chance Month, referred to “justice-involved individuals” when it meant people with criminal records. California’s End of Life Option Act uses the phrase “aid-in-dying drug” and provides that death under the statute does not constitute suicide. In both cases, the law’s hard edge is sanded off before the debate begins.
The bottom line
A free people cannot stay free if they let other people rename reality for them. Miller’s point on CNN was not a trivia fight about vocabulary. It was a warning. When the press and the political class replace “illegal alien” with “undocumented,” “abortion” with “choice” or “reproductive health care,” and a riot with a “mostly peaceful protest,” they are not being polite. They are trying to win the argument without having it.
The cure is simple, and it costs nothing but a little courage. Use the word that tells the truth. If a policy is sound, it can survive its own name. If it cannot, that is information the Republic is entitled to have.
