Five European Countries Announce a Rwanda Return Hub for Rejected Asylum Seekers

Denmark, Austria, Germany, the Netherlands and Greece announced a partnership with Rwanda on Monday to set up the first European Union return hub outside the bloc, for people who have no legal right to stay in Europe, Euronews reported. The announcement was made in Vienna, with Rwanda’s Vincent Biruta standing alongside the ministers.

What the five countries announced

Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen called the agreement “a game changer.” “We will take back control and remove the incentive for illegal migration,” she said. In a joint statement, the five countries said the plan would contribute to “dismantling the business model of smugglers” and “relieving the burden on our population,” the Guardian reported.

The plan is a pilot. The first facility is expected to hold about 100 people at a time, and officials are aiming for the first transfers in 2027, according to Euronews and the Dutch government. Only rejected asylum seekers who are subject to enforceable return decisions will be sent, minors are excluded, and the first phase covers single men. The Netherlands said it will focus on people from Rwanda’s region. Germany will target migrants who refuse to cooperate with identity checks and come from countries reluctant to take back their own nationals, Euronews reported.

The Dutch government said Rwanda will host the migrants in an open, temporary facility, with a right of residence, access to education, the labor market, health care and the legal system. They can return to their home countries at any time. The five countries will pay the costs. No estimate was given on Monday, and negotiations with Rwanda are still under way. Euronews reported that Denmark is set to sign a separate migration partnership with Kigali next week.

The five are the first to use the EU’s newly agreed returns law, which allows people who have exhausted their appeals to be sent to a third country, the Guardian reported.

The opposition

Spain’s Socialist prime minister, Pedro Sánchez, said he sees no “future or humanity” in the plan. French Green lawmaker Mélissa Camara called it “an agreement of shame.” Officials involved expect legal challenges, the Guardian reported, and the five governments say the scheme follows human rights law.

The legal hurdles

Britain tried this first, and it is worth remembering how that ended. The first deportation flight to Rwanda, in June 2022, was grounded at the last minute by a late-night order from the European Court of Human Rights. In November 2023 the U.K. Supreme Court ruled the plan unlawful, finding that Rwanda was not a safe country to send people. Rishi Sunak’s government answered in April 2024 by passing the Safety of Rwanda Act, a law declaring that it was. Then Keir Starmer scrapped the whole scheme in his first week in office in July 2024. Not a single asylum seeker was ever sent, even though Britain had already paid Rwanda hundreds of millions of pounds.

The European plan is built differently. Britain wanted to send new arrivals to Rwanda to have their asylum claims heard there. This hub is only for people who have already lost their cases and exhausted their appeals. Even so, the European Court of Human Rights bars transfers to places where people face rights violations, and the EU law requires that the receiving country respect international human rights standards, so the courts will be watching closely.

The bottom line

I read this as five European governments admitting that a removal order nobody enforces is not worth the paper it is printed on. For years Europe’s leaders let people who lost their asylum cases stay, and the result is the political climate we are watching on that continent now. Frederiksen’s phrase, “take back control,” is the same demand American voters made for the border.

Our country is further along. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said Monday that border crossings are at historic lows and deportations at historic highs, and the White House says there have been 18 straight months of zero releases at the southern border. Those results came from enforcing the law the way it was written.

The caution for us is in the British ruling. A policy has to be drafted so that it survives the courts, and it has to be carried out. I want the results we have protected in court and in Congress.