The Senate confirmed Daniel Domenico to the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday by a vote of 51-46, a party-line vote, according to the Senate’s floor log. Republicans are working to fit as many more judges as they can into the weeks before Democrats take the Senate in January.
The pace
Reuters reported that the Senate had confirmed 57 of President Trump’s judges in his second term before Domenico, with 23 nominees pending. Senate Majority Leader John Thune said Monday that judicial confirmations are a top priority while Republicans hold the chamber. “We expect all judicial nominees pending in the Senate to be confirmed this year,” a White House official told Reuters.
Domenico was Trump’s only first-term appointee to Colorado’s federal trial court. He will replace Judge Timothy Tymkovich, a George W. Bush appointee taking senior status, Colorado Politics reported. As a trial judge he ruled for a Catholic health clinic in a fight over a state ban on “abortion reversal” treatment and required Colorado to accept a Christian preschool into its universal pre-kindergarten program, the paper reported.
Reuters noted that roughly one-third of active federal judges are now Trump appointees, including three members of the Supreme Court’s 6-3 conservative majority.
Where Republicans are pushing back
Reuters reported that a handful of Republicans have blocked or cast doubt on three nominees chosen for their home states. Under the Senate’s blue slip custom, home-state senators can block trial court nominees by withholding a form of support, and two outgoing Judiciary Committee members, Thom Tillis of North Carolina and John Cornyn of Texas, can deny the votes needed to advance them.
The White House withdrew Judge Lee Rudofsky’s nomination to the Eighth Circuit and replaced him with Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland after Arkansas Sens. John Boozman and Tom Cotton opposed Rudofsky. Oklahoma Sen. Alan Armstrong withdrew his support for Zach West, a lawyer in the state attorney general’s office whom conservative legal activists have praised for defending abortion restrictions. Tillis said he will keep blocking West for now. “When I’ve got two Republicans from the state telling me to move on it, I move on it,” Tillis said. “If I have one or more asking me not to, then I’m not.”
Cornyn has not committed to T. Elliot Gaiser, a Dallas nominee who leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel and was chosen without the usual Texas screening process. Without Cornyn’s blue slip, Gaiser cannot appear at Wednesday’s Judiciary Committee hearing. Tillis said senators deserve “respect” from the White House when it picks judges for their states.
The Democratic vote
Colorado’s two Democratic senators, Michael Bennet and John Hickenlooper, voted against Domenico. After his June hearing they said they had concerns about his support for the government’s view of its immigration detention authority and his refusal to acknowledge Trump’s 2020 loss, Colorado Politics reported.
The bottom line
Lifetime judgeships are the most lasting result a president and a Senate majority can deliver, and I want every qualified nominee confirmed while Republicans can still do it. With Democrats holding the Senate in January, the nominees who are not confirmed by then are unlikely to be confirmed at all.
I understand why home-state senators want a say, and Tillis and Cornyn are acting within Senate custom. But Cornyn lost his primary to a Trump-backed challenger, Tillis is retiring, and the calendar is short for everyone. The White House and the senators involved should settle these three nominations this week, with nominees who can get through committee.
