Trump, Xi and Putin Hold First Three-Way Talks in Shenzhen on Nuclear Arms

President Trump sat down Thursday with China’s Xi Jinping and Russia’s Vladimir Putin at Kylin Villa in Shenzhen, the first formal three-way meeting ever held among the leaders of the world’s three largest nuclear powers. This updates our Nov. 18 report on Trump’s arrival in Shenzhen.

The talks ran about an hour and a half, past the one-hour slot set aside for them, according to Chinese state media as reported by the Guardian. No agreement had been announced when the meeting ended.

What Trump told the other two

“We are really making history,” Trump said in his opening remarks, according to the Guardian. He said the three countries are “uniquely positioned” to discuss reducing their nuclear stockpiles, and he added, “It’s not an easy thing to do – give them up.”

Reuters quoted him telling Xi and Putin, “No peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement.” Trump also called the International Criminal Court “out of control,” according to Reuters.

New START, the last treaty limiting American and Russian nuclear weapons, expired in February, and Trump has said he wants a new deal that includes China. Beijing has signaled it is unlikely to accept limits on its smaller arsenal, the Guardian reported.

What Xi and Putin said

Xi said “every effort must be made to prevent nuclear war” and called for nuclear weapons to be comprehensively prohibited and destroyed, according to China’s Xinhua news agency. Xinhua said Xi described the meeting as being of “groundbreaking significance.”

Putin said the three countries have “many converging interests” in settling conflicts, including the war in Ukraine, and a “shared responsibility for maintaining international peace and security.”

The meetings before the meeting

Trump met Putin one-on-one earlier Thursday for 35 to 40 minutes, Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov told the state news agency Tass. Ushakov said they discussed Ukraine, and the Kremlin said Putin came out in an “excellent” mood.

Trump then met Xi. Before the meeting he said the two countries had now split tariffs “in a fair way” through the Board of Trade they agreed to form in Beijing in May. China’s readout of that meeting carried a warning on Taiwan, saying Washington “must keep doing the right thing to avoid major setbacks.” The same Chinese readout quoted Trump as saying the United States “does not support Taiwan independence.” I have not seen a White House account of that exchange.

Jared Kushner said Thursday he would travel to Berlin with special envoy Steve Witkoff for consultations with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and European leaders, the Guardian reported.

British Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch called the meeting “disturbing” on BBC radio and said the three leaders looked like they were trying to “carve up the world between them.”

The bottom line

I think the president was right to sit at that table. The two men across from him command the world’s other two largest nuclear arsenals, and no treaty now limits Russia’s weapons or China’s. Ronald Reagan got the INF Treaty by negotiating with the Soviets, and talking costs us nothing as long as we give nothing away.

I do want to hear the White House describe the Taiwan exchange in its own words. Beijing’s readout is written to serve Beijing, and Americans should not learn what our president said about Taiwan from Chinese state media.

Sending Kushner and Witkoff to Berlin to meet Zelenskyy is the right next step. Any peace in Ukraine has to include the Ukrainians, and the talks in Berlin will show whether Thursday moved that war any closer to an end.