Supreme Court Passes on Key Maryland Gun Case, but Justice Thomas Signals a Future Fight

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a Second Amendment challenge to Maryland’s ban on carrying guns in a long list of “sensitive places,” leaving the state’s 2023 law in place. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote separately to say he doubts the law holds up and that the court should take on the question in a narrower case.

What Maryland bans

The case, Novotny v. Moore, challenged Maryland laws that ban carrying firearms in places including government buildings, school grounds, public transportation, state parks, stadiums and places that sell alcohol, SCOTUSblog reported. Maryland Matters reported that the 2023 law added or amended restrictions covering daycare facilities, schools, hospitals, government buildings and special event and entertainment areas, and that the list also reaches amusement parks.

In January, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit upheld most of the law. The court relied on the line in the Supreme Court’s 2022 Bruen decision saying the right to carry in public does not extend to “sensitive places.” The challengers argued that Bruen made clear that exception is a “narrow” one, SCOTUSblog reported.

What Thomas wrote

Thomas said he is “skeptical” of the 4th Circuit’s conclusion that each of the challenged restrictions “is consistent with this Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation” in sensitive places. He agreed the court should not take this case, because “the breadth” of the challenge “would complicate” the court’s review.

“In an appropriate and more narrowly focused case, however, we should consider the scope of States’ authority to ban firearms in ‘sensitive places,'” Thomas wrote.

The gun groups are not giving up

The Second Amendment Foundation, one of the petitioners, said it was “disappointed.” Bill Sack, the group’s senior director of legal operations, said Maryland “has extinguished the Second Amendment rights of its residents” by creating “multiple categories of so-called sensitive places,” according to Maryland Matters.

“We are encouraged, however, with Justice Thomas’ statement in which he casts serious doubt as to the constitutionality of laws like Maryland’s,” Sack wrote. The foundation has a narrower case pending before the court that targets New York’s ban on carrying in public parks.

Maryland Shall Issue, another petitioner, said it would “continue to press appropriate challenges to misguided legislation that is designed for no other reason than to eviscerate the general right to publicly carry arms for self-defense.”

The decision came a week after a federal district judge in Maryland upheld a similar Montgomery County law, dismissing a challenge brought by the U.S. Justice Department, Maryland Matters reported.

Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown, a Democrat, called the denial “a clear victory for public safety in our state.”

The bottom line

I am disappointed the court let this law stand, yet I understand why Thomas went along. Maryland wrote a ban so broad that one case cannot test every piece of it, and that breadth is the problem. When a state bans lawful carry on transit, in parks, at events and anywhere alcohol is sold, a permit holder has very few places left to carry.

Bruen said the sensitive-places exception was supposed to be narrow, and states like Maryland have spent four years trying to swallow the rule with it. Thomas has now said in writing that the court should step in, and the New York parks case gives it a clean chance to do so.

I am also so glad this Justice Department is in court defending the Second Amendment against local bans instead of looking the other way. The fight is not over, and the next case should be the one that restores the right to carry for law-abiding Americans.