The full 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday refused to rehear Democratic Rep. LaMonica McIver’s bid to throw out federal charges that she assaulted and interfered with immigration officers outside Newark’s Delaney Hall detention center in May 2025.
OMG Democrat Rep LaMonica McIver is facing 3 counts and up to 17 years in prison Assaulting law enforcement is a crime. Obstructing immigration enforcement officials is a crime. NO ONE IS ABOVE THE LAW https://t.co/sfDefLM2qb
— Libs of TikTok (@libsoftiktok) June 10, 2025
What the court did
The order, dated Nov. 19, says that no judge on the original panel asked for rehearing and that “a majority of the judges of the circuit in regular service” did not vote for it. Only three judges, Restrepo, Krause and Montgomery-Reeves, voted to grant the New Jersey Democrat’s petition, according to the order. NorthJersey.com described it as a 10-3 decision.
That leaves in place the August ruling by a three-judge panel, which held 2-1 that the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause does not shield McIver for the physical acts charged in the indictment. “Count One neither charges Congresswoman McIver for an act that is legislative in nature nor requires that she answer for any legislative act,” Judge Cindy Chung, a Biden appointee, wrote for the majority, as quoted by the New Jersey Globe. The panel let two counts stand and sent a broader third count back to U.S. District Judge Jamel Semper for a closer look.
What she is charged with
The case grew out of a May 9, 2025, oversight visit that McIver made to Delaney Hall with two other House Democrats. When federal agents moved to arrest Newark Mayor Ras Baraka outside the gate, federal officials say McIver “slammed her forearm” into a Homeland Security agent and “forcibly” struck a deportation officer, the Guardian reported.
McIver is not backing down. On Wednesday, the day before the ruling, she told Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, “You are killing people,” according to the Guardian.
After the order came down, she said in a statement, “Because of a weaponized Department of Justice, and because I dared to do my job and conduct oversight of ICE, I am facing 17 years in prison.” She added that the decision brings the country “one step closer to a world in which the president of the United States can try to imprison people simply because he does not like what they stand for.” She said her lawyers are “looking at every possible option.”
Her defenders
New Jersey Democrats have rallied around her. After the August ruling, Gov. Mikie Sherrill called the prosecution “a brazen, unlawful abuse of power and a direct attack on congressional oversight,” and Rep. Frank Pallone said McIver “was simply doing her job,” the New Jersey Globe reported.
The bottom line
The courts got this right, twice now. A seat in Congress gives a member the right to inspect a federal detention center. It has never given anyone the right to put hands on the officers doing their jobs outside it. Even a panel majority written by a Biden appointee saw that, and most of the full court refused to second-guess it.
McIver’s answer is to call the Justice Department “weaponized” and to tell the homeland security secretary that his agency is “killing people.” That kind of rhetoric does nothing for the officers who carry out lawful arrests and already face hostile crowds at the gate, as they did at Delaney Hall.
She is entitled to her day in court, and a jury should now hear the evidence. What she is not entitled to is a special exemption from the law every other American has to follow when federal officers are making an arrest, and the 3rd Circuit was right to deny her one.
