Phantom Patients, Fake Data: The Fraud That Buried a Cheap COVID Drug

A post by Liz Churchill that has drawn more than 220,000 views on X since Wednesday night has put the Surgisphere study, one of the worst scientific scandals of the pandemic, back in front of the public. The Lancet, an internationally recognized medical publication of great repute, published it in May 2020 and retracted it two weeks later.

“They invented 96,000 patients that never existed…got The Lancet to publish it…and used it to kill a cheap drug overnight,” Churchill wrote. I went back through the record, and the core of what she describes is documented.

What The Lancet published

On May 22, 2020, The Lancet ran a study led by Harvard cardiologist Mandeep Mehra that claimed records of more than 96,000 COVID patients in 671 hospitals. It found no benefit from hydroxychloroquine and linked the drug to dangerous heart rhythms. The data came from Surgisphere, a small Chicago-based company run by co-author Sapan Desai.

The World Health Organization and several countries suspended randomized trials of the drug, the Guardian reported. Science magazine said the paper “had had a global impact.”

How it fell apart

A Guardian investigation found inconsistencies in the data. An independent auditor was hired to confirm the database was real and accurate, and Surgisphere refused to hand over the full dataset, its client contracts or its audit report.

On June 4, 2020, Mehra and two co-authors asked for a retraction. “We can no longer vouch for the veracity of the primary data sources,” they wrote. The New England Journal of Medicine retracted a second Surgisphere paper by Mehra and Desai the same week.

The Lancet’s editor, Richard Horton, told the Guardian, “This is a shocking example of research misconduct in the middle of a global health emergency.” Mehra said in a statement that he “did not do enough to ensure that the data source was appropriate,” adding, “I am truly sorry.” Desai declined to comment to Reuters.

Surgisphere vanished. The Scientist reported in late 2020 that Desai had inactivated his medical licenses in Illinois and Ohio. I found no record of criminal charges against anyone involved.

The question about the vaccine

Churchill wrote that the drug was killed “so they could get Emergency Use Authorization for the ‘Covid Vaccine.'” That is her argument about motive, and it has not been proven. The question rests on a real legal rule, though. The FDA may grant emergency authorization only when there are “no adequate, approved, and available alternatives.” The FDA revoked its own emergency authorization for hydroxychloroquine on June 15, 2020, and authorized the first COVID vaccine on Dec. 11, 2020. Many Americans are asking whether discrediting a cheap, widely available drug made that test easier to meet.

In fairness, Britain’s large randomized RECOVERY trial later found that hospitalized patients given hydroxychloroquine did not die at lower rates than patients on usual care.

The bottom line

This was a disgrace. Surgisphere produced numbers it would not let anyone check, and four authors put their names on them. The Lancet published them in the middle of a pandemic, and the WHO halted trials around the world on the strength of a database no one had verified.

The later trials do not excuse any of it. Honest science reaches its answers on honest data. For two weeks, the public was told to trust the experts while the experts had skipped the most basic check.

Churchill’s question deserves an answer under oath. Congress and HHS should demand every record of how Surgisphere’s data reached The Lancet and the WHO, and anyone who knowingly passed off unverifiable data as medical evidence should face consequences, which so far no one has.